Cakes

Start Your Cake Order!

We pride ourselves on baking everything from scratch without the use of mixes, powders, preservatives, or fillers.


To make an order please call 

716-754-2300 or email 

Calista@villagebakeshoppe.com


Round Cakes


6" Round *serves 6-8
8" Round *serves 10-14
9" Round *serves 15-25
10" Round *serves 30-45
12" Round *serves 45-55
14" Round *serves 55-75
*Square, Hexagon, Oval & Octagon shapes also available in some sizes!


Sheet Cakes


1/4 Sheet *serves up to 40 people
1/2 Sheet *serves up to 80 people 

Cake Flavor Menu

Traditional Birthday Cakes

a birthday cake that says happy birthday karen on it
a birthday cake with pink and white roses on it is on a table .
a birthday cake for alexis is in a box
a cake that says happy birthday mom on it
a cake that says happy birthday grandma on it
a birthday cake that says happy birthday abigail on it
a birthday cake for jordan is in a box
a birthday cake with the name whitney on it
a birthday cake with strawberries and flowers on it
a cake with pink frosting and macarons on it
a black and white birthday cake says happy 30th birthday samantha
a birthday cake that says happy birthday anne 16 on it
a birthday cake that says happy 2nd birthday mariella
a cake that says happy 16th birthday on it
a cake that says happy birthday lisa on it
a birthday cake that says happy birthday sophia on it
a purple birthday cake with white frosting and roses
View more

1st Birthday Cakes

a cake with the name baylor on it
a cake with a caterpillar on top of it
a cake with a moose on top of a tree stump .
a birthday cake with a pizza on top of it
a cake with mickey mouse and minnie mouse on top of it
a cake with a llama and cactus on it is in a box .
a pink cake with minnie mouse ears and a white bow
a cake with mermaids and seashells on it is in a box .
a birthday cake with a fox and owls on it
a pink and green cake with an ice cream cone on top
a birthday cake for roman with a shark on it
a cake with the lion king characters on it
a black and white cake with ladybugs on it is on a table .
a birthday cake for julie sits on a table
a cake that says happy 1st birthday on it
a birthday cake that says happy 1st birthday ollie
a birthday cake with a crab whale and anchor on it
a birthday cake with a pumpkin and the number 1 on it
a woman stands next to two babies and a birthday cake with the name brooklyn on it
a cake that says happy 1st birthday noah on it
a 1st birthday cake with a palm tree on top
a number 1 cake with the name elliot on it
a birthday cake is sitting on a table with a wooden wall in the background .
a yellow cake with elmo on it is in a box
a 1st birthday cake for george with a curious monkey on it
a cake decorated with mermaid tails and seashells is in a box .
a cake that says happy 1st birthday caden on it
a yellow and green birthday cake for ozzie joseph
a mickey mouse birthday cake with the number 1 on top
a mickey mouse cake with the name robert on it
a first birthday cake for jimmy with a cat in the hat on top
a birthday cake with mickey mouse and minnie mouse on it
a cake that says happy 1st birthday reese on it
a cake with a tiger face and the name luke on it
View more

Not Your Typical Birthday Cakes

a pink birthday cake with candy and lollipops on top
a blue and orange cake with a bow tie and glasses on top .
a cake with winnie the pooh tigger and piglet on it
a pikachu cake with the words happy birthday max written on it
a construction themed birthday cake for tom roll
a blue cake with farm animals and the number 2 on it
a purple cake with roblox characters on it
a birthday cake with a storm trooper face on it
a cake with a caterpillar on top of it
a cake with shrek and a sign that says keep out
a birthday cake for chase with a lego face on it
a cake with a moose on top of a tree stump .
a birthday cake with a monster on top and the number 3 on it
a black and white birthday cake with a smiley face on it
a birthday cake with captain america iron man hulk and spider man on it
a cake with mickey mouse and minnie mouse on top of it
a blue cake with the word fortnite on it
a cake with a circus theme and the number 2 on it
a birthday cake for quinn with peppa pig on top
a cake with a dog , kayak , snowboard , and fishing rod on it .
a blue and green birthday cake with a dinosaur on top
a cake with jesus on top of it in a box
a birthday cake in a box that says happy birthday alexa
a yellow cake with a purple house on top that says house party
a cake that looks like a book called night of the dummy
a birthday cake for a boy with construction vehicles on it
a birthday cake with trolls and lollipops on it
a cake with a lion king theme is in a box .
a pink cake with flowers and a flamingo on top
a yellow cake that says happy 3rd birthday on it
a birthday cake with a fox face on it
a purple and black birthday cake is in a box
a blue and white cake with a sailboat on top of it .
a green cake with the name mason on it
a cake with hulk captain america and iron man on it
a teapot that says we 're all mad here
a cake that looks like elmo from sesame street
a purple cup with the name theresa on it
a blue cake with spongebob on top and the words what 's better than 6 7
a harry potter cake with a sorting hat on top
a cake with a llama and cactus on it is in a box .
a pink cake with minnie mouse ears and a white bow
a pink and blue paw patrol birthday cake
a birthday cake with a snowman on top that says happy 2nd birthday mckenzie
a green cake with an xbox logo on it
a cake with a baby yoda on top of it
a little girl is sitting at a table with a birthday cake in the shape of a barbie doll .
a birthday cake with animals on it that says happy birthday vitol
a unicorn cake with purple flowers and a gold horn is in a box .
a birthday cake for a little girl named elliana
a spongebob squarepants cake for tyler 9
a black and white star wars cake with the name kinslee on it
a birthday cake with soldiers on it and the words happy birthday jack
a birthday cake with a spider man face on it
a birthday cake with a mermaid tail on top
a birthday cake for a boy named dylan
a birthday cake for daniel with a school bus on it
a birthday cake in the shape of a school bus
a birthday cake with a tent on top of it
a birthday cake for gabriella with flowers and butterflies
a birthday cake with goofy 's face on it
a frozen cake with elsa and olaf on it
a lol surprise cake for sofia is in a box .
a cake that says happy 3rd birthday josefina on it
a cake with a picture of elsa on it
a black and white checkered birthday cake for cara
a birthday cake with donuts and sprinkles on it
a cake with the lion king characters on it
a birthday cake with a grumpy cat face on it
a leopard print birthday cake with a pink bow
a birthday cake for brian with an airplane on top
a pink minnie mouse cake with ears and a bow is on a table .
a honey pot with the word hunny on it
a blue cake with a rainbow mane and tail
a birthday cake with roses and macarons on it is in a box .
a white teapot decorated with pink and blue flowers
a star wars birthday cake with bb-8 on top
a cake with a doll on top that says happy 7th birthday
a cake that looks like a crab is sitting on a table .
a birthday cake with south park characters on it
a minnie mouse cake with the name paige on it
a blue and yellow cake with the name kewarren on it
a birthday cake with a horse and cowboy boots on it
a blue cake with pj masks on it is on a wooden table .
a pink and white birthday cake with the number 16 on top
a cake that looks like a video game controller says happy 14th birthday taylor
a spiderman cake with a city in the background
a birthday cake with the name jaxon on it
a 70th birthday cake with antlers on it
a vans off the wall cake with a checkered background
two unicorn birthday cakes are sitting on a counter .
a birthday cake that says happy 70th birthday from it 's a wonderful life
a birthday cake with a pineapple and the number 2 on it
a birthday cake with a chanel box on top
a cake that says happy 2nd birthday ara on it
a cake decorated with makeup and the name ai mee
a birthday cake with red roses and a horseshoe on it
a cake with snowflakes and the name akerra on it
a cake with a doll on it that says happy 7th birthday
a birthday cake with a lightning mcqueen car on it
a cake in the shape of a red lip says happy 60th birthday sue
a cake with a grumpy cat face on it
a birthday cake with a creeper face on it
a cake that looks like a birdhouse with flowers and a bird on it
a birthday cake for lucas with buzz lightyear and woody on it
a birthday cake with a snowman on a surfboard
a birthday cake with sesame street characters on it
a birthday cake with a mermaid tail on top
a birthday cake with spiderman superman and batman on it
a birthday cake for a boy named dylan
a cake with a red ford car on top of it
a birthday cake with a cat in the hat on it
a cake that says happy 2nd birthday alijah on it
a cake in the shape of a snowman with the name ruby on it
a birthday cake is sitting on a table with a wooden wall in the background .
a pink and white cake with a dress on top
a white cake with the name abigail on it
a cake with a dinosaur on top of it
a cake with flowers and a clock on top of it
a blue birthday cake with a cinderella shoe on top
a yellow cake with elmo on it is in a box
a star wars cake that says may the fortieth be with you eric
a pink cake with boxing gloves and the words happy 6th birthday joelle
a birthday cake with the name gabriel on it
a scooby doo cake with scooby doo and the mystery machine on it
a birthday cake with a galaxy design on it
a cake that looks like a polo shirt with the number 18 on it
a scooby doo cake with the number 3 on it
a cake decorated with mermaid tails and seashells is in a box .
a birthday cake that looks like a board game
a birthday cake with a green hulk fist on top
a birthday cake with a unicorn on top of it
a birthday cake with a carpet on top of it
a birthday cake for emma with a unicorn on top
a birthday cake for carter with a blue dinosaur on it
a cake that says happy 2nd birthday bryce on it
a birthday cake in the shape of the number 2
a cake in the shape of the number 20 decorated with berries and flowers
a birthday cake that says happy birthday anne 16 on it
a mickey mouse cake with the name robert on it
a troll birthday cake with a rainbow and a number 5 candle
a birthday cake in the shape of the number 13
a blue paw patrol birthday cake with paw prints on it
a black and white birthday cake with pink roses and a gold bow
a cake that says happy 2nd birthday ara on it
a purple alice in wonderland cake with a top hat on it
a black cake with silver macarons on top is in a box .
a birthday cake for a little girl named tessa
a birthday cake in the shape of a fire truck
a birthday cake with pink and black polka dots and the number 30 on top
a birthday cake that says happy 90th birthday russ
a cake with minions dressed as captain america thor and hulk
View more

Adult Birthday Cakes

Tuxedo Cake
a birthday cake with a storm trooper face on it
a tie dye birthday cake with a peace sign on it
a pink and white birthday cake with strawberries and macarons
a black and white birthday cake with a smiley face on it
a cake with a dog , kayak , snowboard , and fishing rod on it .
a birthday cake with a fish and a fishing rod on it
a cake in the shape of a shoe says happy 30th birthday dave
a birthday cake with the number 40 on it
a birthday cake with a shark on top of it
a yellow cake with a purple house on top that says house party
a cake that looks like a book called night of the dummy
a 50th birthday cake with a tractor on top
a pink cake with flowers and a flamingo on top
a purple and black birthday cake is in a box
a teapot that says we 're all mad here
a purple cup with the name theresa on it
a cake that looks like a box of cigars
a birthday cake with a bowling alley scene on it
a cake that says happy 21st molly on it
a birthday cake with animals on it that says happy birthday vitol
a birthday cake in the shape of a drum with drumsticks on it
a birthday cake for gabriella with flowers and butterflies
a yellow cake with the words have a blast on it
a cake that says ' vinnie hit the big 40 ' on it
a black and white checkered birthday cake for cara
a cake that looks like hay bales with apples on top
a leopard print birthday cake with a pink bow
a cake that has the name jason on it
a purple birthday cake with purple frosting and silver sprinkles
a cake with a sailboat and the number 525 on it
a gucci box with a pair of sandals on top of it
a purple birthday cake with white roses on it
a birthday cake with roses and macarons on it is in a box .
a cake in the shape of a can of froy-topper beer
a cake with a heart and the number 30 on it
a cake that looks like a barrel of jameson whiskey
a 70th birthday cake with antlers on it
a birthday cake that says happy 70th birthday from it 's a wonderful life
a yellow and black cake with the number 70 on top
a cake in the shape of a red lip says happy 60th birthday sue
a cake that looks like a birdhouse with flowers and a bird on it
a cake in the shape of a bottle of jagermeister
a birthday cake with a boat on top of it
a birthday cake for frances with a coffin and grave
a cake with a red ford car on top of it
a cake in the shape of a snowman with the name ruby on it
a star wars cake that says may the fortieth be with you eric
a cake that looks like a polo shirt with the number 18 on it
a 60th birthday cake in the shape of a wine barrel
a birthday cake that says happy birthday mr. awesome
a birthday cake in the shape of a wooden barrel
a cake that says aged to perfection on it
a birthday cake with a carpet on top of it
a cake in the shape of the number 20 decorated with berries and flowers
a birthday cake that says happy birthday anne 16 on it
a black and white birthday cake with pink roses and a gold bow
a cake with a sewing machine and scissors on it
a black cake with silver macarons on top is in a box .
a birthday cake with a bottle of wine on top
a pink and white birthday cake with the number 30 on top
a birthday cake with pink and black polka dots and the number 30 on top
a birthday cake that looks like a gift box
a birthday cake that says happy 90th birthday russ
a birthday cake with a purple bow and tag that says happy birthday
View more

Sports Themed Cakes

a red white and blue birthday cake for logan
a cake in the shape of a shoe says happy 30th birthday dave
a birthday cake with a buffalo bills logo on it
a three tiered cake with a cubs logo on it
a cake with a golf cart on top that says erik is fore-tee
a new york yankees birthday cake for shelly
a cake with a jordan shoe on top of it
a birthday cake for brandon with a baseball bat and glove
a cake in the shape of a buffalo bills hat
a cake that says the perfect brew to say i do
a red white and blue birthday cake for tyler
a number 1 cake with the name elliot on it
a pink cake with boxing gloves and the words happy 6th birthday joelle
View more

Graduation Cakes

a cake with congratulations bridget written on it
a black and gold graduation cake with a graduation cap on top
a cake with a graduation cap on top of it
a cake that says congrats on your retirement nurse sue
a cake with a stethoscope and x-ray on it is on a table .
a red and black jacket with the letter m on it
a cake that says congratulations we are so proud of you
a cake with a graduation cap and the year 2020 on it
a cake that says congratulations cameron class of 2019
a cake that says congratulations anna class of 2020
a graduation cake with congratulations written on it
a cake with a graduation cap on top of it .
a blue and gold cake with a graduation cap on top
a cake that says congratulations rain su grad 2020
a cake with a stethoscope and the word fnp on it
View more

Occasion Cakes

a cake that says welcome to the family on it
a man is sitting at a table with a cake that says thank you
a cake with a yellow house and a white picket fence
a cake that says united states navy on it
a cake with a fireman 's helmet and the letter j on top
a lion 's international cake with yellow and blue flowers
a pink and gold cake with white roses on top
three women are posing for a picture in front of a cake
a cake with a shovel on top that says celebrate 4
a cake that says congratulations on your retirement
a cake that says happy retirement connie on it
a star shaped cake with red white and blue stars on it
a starks jersey with the number 44 on it
View more

Bridal Shower Cakes

a cake with flowers on top of it on a table
a cake that looks like a tree stump with mushrooms and pine cones on it
a white cake with pink flowers on top of it
a cake that says congratulations tyler and rachel on it
a white cake with roses on top is sitting on a table .
a two tiered cake with pink roses on top is on a table .
a pink and white cake with roses on it
a white cake with macarons and flowers on top
a white and pink cake with roses on top
a white cake with a pink bow and a topper that says mrs. and mr.
a cake with a picture of a wedding dress on it
a three tiered cake with gold frosting and flowers on a white plate .
a white cake with white frosting and gold sprinkles is in a box .
a cake that says congratulations on it
a cake that says welcome lady james and great jesus on it
a wedding cake decorated with succulents and flowers is sitting on a white plate on a table .
a white cake with a bow on top is in a box .
a white cake with purple swirls and flowers on it
a pink cake with flowers and leaves on it is on a table .
a cake with a picture of a bride on it
a cake in the shape of a teapot decorated with flowers and pearls
a cake that says congratulations lauren and frankie on it
a pink cake with pink flowers on top of it
a white cake with pink roses and swirls on it
a cake with a pocket watch and playing cards on it
a cake in the shape of a mad hatter 's hat
a wedding cake with pink frosting and pink roses is sitting on a table .
a three tiered cake with flowers on top is in a cardboard box .
View more

Rehearsal Cakes

a blue and white cake with red stripes on it
a new york yankees cake with red white and blue stripes
a buffalo bills cake with two pugs on top of it .
a cake that looks like a ball with a letter s on it
a game of thrones cake with a throne on top
a cake that looks like a r2d2 wearing a tuxedo
a green and white cake with a golf ball on top of it .
a cake that says central perk on it
a cake with a sabres logo on it
a cake with a new york yankees logo on it
a ny hat sits next to a tray of food
a cake with a man playing a guitar and a woman sitting on it
a cake with a man and a woman laying on a bed
a cake in the shape of an armadillo on a table
a philadelphia flyers cake with a cat on top
View more

Gender Reveal Cakes

a cake that looks like a baby 's belly is in a box
a cake that says staches or lashes on it
a blue and pink cake with ice cream cones and a banner that says what 's the soup
a cake that says what will it bee on it
a baby shower cake with pink and blue frosting

Baby Shower Cakes

a baby shower cake for sarah and justin with an elephant on top
a cake that says welcome baby here on it
a cake with an elephant on top of it
a cake that looks like a tree stump with mushrooms and pine cones on it
a white cake with a top hat , bow tie and mustache on it .
a baby shower cake with bees and a beehive on it
a pink and white cake with a shoe on top
a baby shower cake with a pink stroller on top
a cake with a sun on top of it is on a table .
a baby shower cake with a baby laying on top of it .
a two tiered cake with pink roses on top is on a table .
a pink and white cake with a little pumpkin topper
a baby shower cake for a girl with two elephants on top
a cake that says welcome baby ella on it
a cake with antlers and flowers on top of it on a table .
a cake with a raccoon and a fox on top of it
a cake that says god bless jenna ann on it
a cake that says congratulations on it
a baby shower cake with a dinosaur and the words welcome baby ozzie
a cake that says welcome baby girl on it
a cake that says congratulations hailey on it
a cake that says it 's a girl on it
a cake that says twinkle twinkle little star on it
a ceramic pot with the word hunny on it
a cake that says welcome lady james and great jesus on it
a cake with two deer on top of it is on a table .
a baby shower cake with a pair of baby shoes on top
a cake with a deer fox and squirrel on it
a cake with antlers and flowers on it is for brooklyn ann
a baby shower cake with a crescent moon and stars on top .
a wedding cake decorated with succulents and flowers is sitting on a white plate on a table .
a cake with three teddy bears and a heart on it
a cake with three teddy bears on top of it
a pink cake with flowers and leaves on it is on a table .
a green and white cake with gus written on it
a cake with an elephant a giraffe and a monkey on it
a cake with two owls and pink flowers on it
a baby shower cake with an elephant holding a heart shaped balloon
a cake that looks like a book with the words welcome muggle merge written on it
a cake with a pair of pink ballet shoes on it
a cake that says it 's a girl on it
a cake that says welcome penny bee on it
a baby shower cake for easton with a baby sleeping on a picnic blanket
a wedding cake with pink frosting and pink roses is sitting on a table .
a cake that says a little pumpkin is on her way
a cake that says welcome baby girl on it
a baby shower cake with a teddy bear on it
a cake with a raccoon and a fox on top of it
a cake that says welcome baby girl on it
View more

Smash Cakes

a baby is sitting next to a giant mickey mouse cupcake
a baby girl is eating a piece of cake .
a baby is sitting on a wooden stump eating a cake .
a cake with bees and a beehive on it is on a wooden table .
two cakes on a cake stand under a banner that says jordan
a unicorn cake is sitting on top of a white cake stand .
a baby is sitting in front of a sesame street cake .
a baby is sitting on the floor eating a cake .
a baby girl wearing a crown is sitting next to a cake .
a baby is sitting on a cake in front of balloons .
a cookie monster cake with a cookie in its mouth
a cupcake with a barn and a cow on it is sitting on a table .
a baby is standing next to a cake on a cake stand .
a cake with the letters bm and a on it
a cake with a house and balloons on it
View more

Religious Cakes

a pink cake with pink roses and white frosting is in a box .
a white cake with pink roses and a gold cross on top
a white and blue cake with a cross on top is sitting on a table .
a cake with a cross and pink roses on it
a cake that looks like a bible that says god bless christopher on his 1st holy communion may 5th 2018
a cake that says god bless empory claire on it
a white cake with a blue cross and the name gabriel on it
a cake that says god bless thompson on it
a cake with a rosary and a cross on it .
a cake with a rosary and a bible on it
a cake that says god bless jeana han on it
a pink and white cake with a gold cross on top
a white cake with pink roses on it is sitting on a table .
a first communion cake for a girl with a pink cross on top
a white cake with a cross on it is in a box
a white cake with a gold cross on it is in a box .
a white cake with pink flowers and a gold cross on top
a cake that says god bless cristine is on a table
a cake in a box that says god bless ara rose
a cake with an elephant and a lion on it
a white and blue cake with a cross on top is sitting on a table .
View more

Cakes That Look Like Food

a birthday cake with strawberries and watermelon on it
a cake that looks like a hamburger with ketchup on it
a cake in the shape of a piece of meat
a pizza cake with pepperoni and cheese on top
a donut cake with pink frosting and sprinkles for ellie 's 9th birthday
a colorful cake with cactus and a taco on top
View more

A Cake For Any Occasion

a white cake with strawberries on top is in a box .
a close up of a cake with whipped cream and sprinkles
a chocolate cake with oreos on top is in a box .
a chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting is in a box .
a cake with chocolate frosting and whipped cream on top
View more

Easter Cakes

Halloween Cakes

a green cake with a witch hat on top of it
a cake with a jason voorhees mask on it
a halloween cake with spider webs and spiders on it
a birthday cake in a box that says happy birthday
a purple birthday cake with spiders on it
a halloween cake with ghosts and sprinkles on it
a cake in the shape of a pumpkin for a 3rd birthday
a pink pumpkin cake with the words happy 1st birthday written on it
a halloween cake with a ghost and pumpkins on top
a halloween cake with bats pumpkins and spiders on it
View more

Christmas Cakes

a christmas cake with poinsettia and holly on it
a christmas cake with a poinsettia on top
a cake with snowmen and trees on it
a cake that says merry christmas on it
a cake that says welcome sydney eloise on it
a birthday cake that says it 's a wonderful life
a chocolate cake with white frosting and red flowers on top
a white cake with cranberries and rosemary on top .
a white cake with a poinsettia and holly on top
a cake with snowmen and trees on it
a christmas cake with a poinsettia on top
a bunch of cupcakes with green frosting and santa hats on them
a tray of chocolate cupcakes decorated to look like snowmen
View more