Cakes

We pride ourselves on baking everything from scratch without the use of mixes, powders, preservatives, or fillers.

To make an order please call 716-754-2300 or email cali@villagebakeshoppe.com

Round Cakes

6" Round *serves 4-10
8" Round *serves 10-14
9" Round *serves 12-20
10" Round *serves 30-45
12" Round *serves 45-55
14" Round *serves 55-75
*Square, Hexagon, Oval & Octagon shapes also available

Sheet Cakes

1/4 Sheet *serves up to 40 people
1/2 Sheet *serves up to 80 people

Cake Flavors

Almond | Apple Spice | Banana | Black Forest | Carrot | Caramel Swirl | Cherry Chip | Chocolate | Coconut | German Chocolate | Funfetti | Lemon | Lemon Swirl | Pumpkin | Marble | Orange Creamsicle | Pineapple | Raspberry Swirl | Red Velvet | Traditional White | Strawberry Swirl | Spice 

Mousse Fillings

Almond | Amaretto | Caramel | Cherry Chip | Chocolate | Coconut | Funfetti | Hazelnut | Lemon | Keylime | Marble | Mint | Mocha | Orange Creamsicle | Oreo | Peanut Butter | Pineapple | Raspberry | Strawberry | Triple berry | White Chocolate

Jam Fillings

Lemon Curd | Raspberry | Strawberry

Other Fillings

Bavarian | Custard | Cannoli | Cream Cheese | Cinnamon Cream Cheese | German Chocolate 

Frosting

Vanilla Buttercream | Chocolate Buttercream | Whipped Cream | Bavarian | Cream Cheese | Cinnamon Cream Cheese

Specialty Cakes

The Hawaiin | Italian Cream Cake | Tiramisu | Pineapple Upside-down cake | Boston Cream Pie

Call today to customize your next occasion cake.

A non-refundable deposit is required for customized and/or fondant decorated cakes. Deposits can be paid in store or over the phone through credit card. 

Birthday Cakes

Traditional Birthday Cakes

Everyday Cakes

Graduation Cakes

Occasion Cakes

Rehearsal Cakes

Gender Reveal Cakes

Smash Cakes

Shower Cakes

Religious Cakes

Cakes That Look Like Food

Halloween Cakes

Christmas Cakes